Online Shop

Pick a Date

CAKES (19)

Cakes Available In Store Today

These cakes are available every day in store for pick-up!6-inch Classic Birthday Cake - Our most beloved flavor: moist vanilla cake filled with house-made berry jam and wrapped in silky vanilla buttercream. The perfect celebration cake. (Colors may vary) Feeds 8 to 10 people.6-inch Double Chocolate Cake - Rich chocolate cake layered with dark chocolate ganache and topped with chocolate buttercream. A decadent treat for true chocolate lovers. Feeds 8 to 10 people.6-inch Rainbow Cake - Five vibrant cake layers in classic rainbow colors, stacked with creamy vanilla buttercream and finished with rainbow sprinkles. A magical choice that delights kids and adults alike. Feeds 8 to 10 people.8-inch Cookies and Milk Cake - A playful twist on two classics: alternating layers of vanilla and chocolate cake with matching buttercreams, generously studded with chunks of house-made chocolate chunk cookies. Like dunking cookies in milk, reimagined as cake. Feeds 10 to 12 people.

$49.00

Classic Birthday Cake (Large)

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Our most beloved flavor: moist vanilla cake filled with house-made berry jam and wrapped in silky vanilla buttercream. The perfect celebration cake.

$49.00

Strawberry Shortcake Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Buttermilk Bakeshop's version of a Strawberry Shortcake! Vanilla cake filled with a thin layer of strawberry jam, fresh strawberries, and meringue buttercream.

$59.60

Rainbow Cake (Large)

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Five vibrant cake layers in classic rainbow colors, stacked with creamy vanilla buttercream and finished with rainbow sprinkles. A magical choice that delights kids and adults alike.

$58.00

Double Chocolate Cake (Large)

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Rich chocolate cake filled with chocolate buttercream. A decadent treat for true chocolate lovers.

$49.00

Pistachio Honey Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Pistachio cake, honey mascarpone filling, fresh black berries on top.

$60.70

Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Dark chocolate cake paired with pure vanilla buttercream. Made with high-quality cocoa and real vanilla beans, this timeless pairing satisfies every sweet craving.

$49.20

Classic Vanilla Cake and Chocolate Buttercream

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Perfectly moist vanilla cake generously frosted with rich, dark chocolate buttercream. A beloved combination that never fails to delight, crafted with premium vanilla.

$49.20

Classic Vanilla Cake and Chocolate Buttercream

Red Velvet Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Classic red velvet layers infused with a hint of cocoa, wrapped in our silky cream cheese frosting. Rich, velvety, and perfectly moist - a timeless Southern favorite that strikes the ideal balance between subtle chocolate notes and tangy sweetness.

$49.00

Cookie Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Select your cookie style:Salted Nutella: Rich chocolate cookie infused with hazelnut spread and finished with sea saltChocolate Chunk: Classic buttery cookie loaded with premium dark chocolate piecesSprinkle: Cheerful sugar cookie studded with rainbow sprinkles

$35.60

Cookies & Milk Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

A playful twist on two classics: alternating layers of vanilla and chocolate cake with matching buttercreams, generously studded with chunks of house-made chocolate chunk cookies. Like dunking cookies in milk, reimagined as cake.

$60.70

Berry Chantilly Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Delicate light vanilla cake with airy, chantilly whipped cream frosting and a fresh berries. The cake has a classy, rustic finish and elegantly decorated with berries on top.

$58.50

Blueberry Yuzu Layer Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Delicate blueberry-yuzu sponge with vanilla buttercream, tangy lemon curd, and blueberry compote.

$58.50

Coconut Dream Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

Moist, coconut dream cake with soft coconut cream, and decorated with coconut flakes.

$58.50

Cranberry Carrot Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Delicious cranberry carrot cake wrapped in our silky cream cheese frosting. Moist, warmly spiced, and irresistibly rich, this cake is perfect for the season.

$60.70

Lemon Lavender Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

An elegant garden-inspired creation: delicate vanilla cake filled with bright, house-made lemon curd, kissed with local honey drizzle, and adorned with lavender buttercream. Each bite brings a harmonious blend of floral and citrus notes.

$60.70

Oreo!

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Whimsical funfetti cake layered with crushed Oreo buttercream, draped with dark chocolate ganache, and topped with colorful M&Ms. A nostalgic fusion of childhood favorites in every slice.

$57.50

The Wedding Slice Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

GF options

A taste of celebration: tender almond cake layered with tart raspberry jam and zesty lemon curd, all enveloped in cloudlike Swiss meringue buttercream. Our signature wedding cake, available by the slice.

$60.70

Vegan Cake

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Choose your perfect plant-based combination: moist vanilla, rich chocolate, or classic red velvet cake paired with silky vanilla or chocolate buttercream. Entirely vegan, completely delicious.

$70.10

Custom Cakes

Get the cake of your dreams! We specialize in creating custom cakes for any occasion, from birthdays to weddings, tailored to your unique vision. Choose from 1000s of designs or upload your own to get a quote.

GET A

QUOTE

CUPCAKES (6)

Cupcake Box

Choose your flavor or get an assorted box of our daily cupcakes.

$3.93

Vegan Cupcake Box

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Choose your flavor or get an assorted box of cupcakes in three different flavors - Vanilla with Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate with Chocolate Buttercream, Red Velvet with Vegan VanillaButtercream

$50.20

Red Velvet Cupcake

Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Frosting

$3.93

Cookies and Cream Cupcake

Delectable chocolate cupcake with a cookies and cream buttercream frosting

$3.93

DIY Cupcakes

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

6 vanilla cupcakes, 6 chocolate cupcakes, one vanilla bag and one chocolate bag, 3 assorted sprinkles.

$49.20

Gluten Free Cupcake Box

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Choose your flavor or get an assorted box of cupcakes in three different flavors - Vanilla with Vanilla Buttercream, Double Chocolate with Chocolate Buttercream, Red Velvet with Cream Cheese Frosting.

$50.20

BARS (10)

Seasonal Bar Box

Try our Favorite Seasonal Bar Flavors. Select your box size and we will have it ready for pick up at the bakery!

$17.40

Bar Box

Order a box of our freshly baked bars now. Choose from the core flavors and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!

$4.40

Brookie

$4.40

Brownie

$4.40

Chocolate Covered Oreos

$3.40

Gluten Free / Vegan Peanut Butter Bar

$4.40

Lemon Bar

$4.40

Raspberry Linzer

$4.40

Vegan Brownie Bar

$4.40

Whoopie Pies

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

$5.38

COOKIES (7)

Cookie Box

Order a box of our freshly baked cookies now. Choose from the core flavors and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!

$4.00

Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$4.00

Sprinkle Cookie

$4.00

Chocolate Almond Oat Cookie

$4.00

Gluten Free / Vegan Chocolate Chunk Cookie

$4.00

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.00

Salted Nutella Cookie

$4.00

DECORATIONS (5)

Rainbow Candles

$4.50

Gold Candles

$4.50

Happy Birthday Cake Topper

$7.50

Number Candle

$4.50

Rose Gold Candles

$4.50

MACARONS (1)

French Macarons

Our classic French macarons showcase delicate almond meringue shells in six signature flavors: rich Madagascar vanilla bean, decadent dark chocolate, bright raspberry, toasted pistachio, aromatic coffee, and indulgent tiramisu. Each flavor is filled with silky buttercream or ganache.

$3.66

CAKE POPS (2)

Assorted Cake Pops

Our assorted dozen box of cake pops are the sweetest, most delicious little treats, perfect for any party or celebration. We offer classic vanilla and double chocolate.

$3.75

Push Up Pops

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

These super fun push up pops are filled to the brim with cake. They are the perfect little party favors or treats.A dozen push up pops come with two flavors, six classic vanilla and six rich double chocolate.

$6.27

MINI SWEETS (4)

Mini Cupcake Box

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Choose your flavor or get an assorted box of our mini cupcakes, perfect for any celebration or party.

$36.00

Mini Cookie Box

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Order a box of our freshly baked mini cookies, perfect for any celebration or party. Choose from the core flavors, and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!

$36.00

Mini Bar Box

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Order a box of our mini bars now. Our favorite flavors and we will have the box ready for pick up at the bakery!

$41.00

The Little Celebration Box

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Our Little Celebration Box is an assortment of classic mini treats.6 mini cookies, 6 mini cupcakes, and 6 mini bar pieces!Perfect for gatherings and celebrations, plus it comes with a free pack of candles!

$50.00

PARTY BUNDLES (3)

Deluxe Sweet Treats Platter

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Delight in our holiday platter featuring our most beloved treats: fresh-baked cookies, decadent cupcakes, festive cake pops, and delicate French macarons.

$126.50

The Party Starter

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Best for: Small gatherings, school events, casual hostingIncludes• 12 assorted cupcakes• 12 assorted cookiesServes: 10–12 people

$79.00

The Sweet Sampler

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Delight in our sweet sampler, featuring our most beloved treats.Best for: First-time customers, indecisive buyersIncludes• 4 cupcakes• 4 cookies• 4 bars or browniesServes: 4–6 people

$45.00

TASTING KIT (3)

Gluten Free Tasting Kit

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Gluten-free tasting kits include eight of our most popular flavors:Classic Birthday: Vanilla cake, raspberry jam, and vanilla buttercream.Wedding cake Slice: Almond cake, lemon curd, raspberry jam, and meringue buttercream.Vanilla Mousse: Vanilla cake with chocolate mousse, fresh strawberries, and meringue buttercream.Red Velvet: Moist red velvet cake with classic cream cheese frosting.The Rocher: Chocolate cake, hazelnut buttercream, and drizzled ganache.Decadent Double Chocolate: Chocolate cake, with chocolate meringue buttercream.Cookies and Milk: Vanilla and chocolate cake with matching buttercream, layered with cookie pieces.Pistachio Honey: Pistachio cake, honey mascarpone filling, and fresh blackberries.

$33.50

Tasting Kit

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Tasting kits include eight of our most popular flavors:Classic Birthday: Vanilla cake, raspberry jam & vanilla buttercreamWedding cake Slice: Almond cake, lemon curd, raspberry jam, and meringue buttercreamVanilla Mousse: Vanilla cake with chocolate mousse, fresh strawberries, and meringue buttercreamRed Velvet: Moist red velvet cake with classic cream cheese frostingThe Rocher: Chocolate cake, hazelnut buttercream, and drizzled ganacheDecadent Double Chocolate: Chocolate cake, with chocolate meringue buttercreamCookies and Milk: Vanilla and chocolate cake with matching buttercream, layered with cookie piecesPistachio Honey: Pistachio cake, and honey mascarpone filling.

$33.50

Vegan Mini Cupcake Tasting Kit

Pre-order (min 2 days notice)

Vegan tasting kits include eight of our most popular vegan flavors:Double Vanilla: Vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream frostingDouble Chocolate: Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream frostingVanilla Chocolate: Vanilla cake with chocolate frostingChocolate Vanilla: Chocolate cake with vanilla frostingRed Velvet: Moist red velvet cake with vanilla frostingRaspberry Lemon: Lemon cake with vanilla frosting and raspberry jamChocolate Hazelnut: Chocolate cake with hazelnut frostingAlmond Lemon: Almond cake with lemon frosting

$33.50

CAKE JARS (1)

Cake In A Jar

Our cake in a jars are fun, portable, and the sweetest things all deliciously packed in mason jar. We have three flavors readily availableVanilla - Classic vanilla cake stacked with creamy vanilla buttercream and finished with rainbow sprinklesChocolate - Rich chocolate cake layered with chocolate buttercream and finished with rainbow sprinklesBanana Pudding - Flavorful vanillla cake with creamy banana pudding, cream, and wafer cookies

$18.30

CARDS (1)

Birthday Card

$6.10

PIES (1)

Salted Nutella Pecan Pie

A Buttermilk twist on our classic pecan pie. Our signature gooey pecan filling swirled with rich Nutella throughout, finished with a salted Nutella drizzle and a sprinkle of sea salt for the perfect balance of sweet and savory.

$5.50